ub.xmlui.mirage2.page-structure.muninLogoub.xmlui.mirage2.page-structure.openResearchArchiveLogo
    • EnglishEnglish
    • norsknorsk
  • Velg spraaknorsk 
    • EnglishEnglish
    • norsknorsk
  • Administrasjon/UB
Vis innførsel 
  •   Hjem
  • Fakultet for humaniora, samfunnsvitenskap og lærerutdanning
  • Institutt for språk og kultur
  • Artikler, rapporter og annet (språk og kultur)
  • Vis innførsel
  •   Hjem
  • Fakultet for humaniora, samfunnsvitenskap og lærerutdanning
  • Institutt for språk og kultur
  • Artikler, rapporter og annet (språk og kultur)
  • Vis innførsel
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Terminology matters on theoretical grounds too!: Coherent grammars cannot be incomplete

Permanent lenke
https://hdl.handle.net/10037/17850
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0272263119000287
Thumbnail
Åpne
article.pdf (98.63Kb)
Akseptert manusversjon (PDF)
Dato
2019-07-04
Type
Journal article
Tidsskriftartikkel
Peer reviewed

Forfatter
Bayram, Fatih; Kupisch, Tanja; Pascual y Cabo, Diego; Rothman, Jason
Sammendrag
Herein, we provide counterargumentation to some of Domínguez, Hicks, and Slabakova's claims that the term incomplete acquisition is conceptually necessary on theoretical grounds for describing the outcome grammars of heritage language bilingualism. Specifically, we clarify their claim that previous challenging of the term in our and others’ work is primarily based on a misconceived belief that incompleteness is intended to describe heritage speakers. We contextualize and problematize their appropriation of descriptive constructs in the adjacent fields of child L1, child 2L1, and adult L2 acquisition as a basis for supporting their general thesis. Relatedly, we conclude that a fundamental blurring of development and ultimate attainment issues is at the core of what, in our view, is flawed reasoning. While we empathize with the well-intentioned spirit of Domínguez et al.’s article—to provide a forum for respectful discussion—we invite the field to engage more directly with the inherent quandary of labeling the coherent grammars of heritage bilinguals in their own right as “incomplete” on the basis of differences to standard varieties.
Forlag
Cambridge University Press (CUP)
Sitering
Bayram F, Kupisch T, Pascual y Cabo D, Rothman J. Terminology matters on theoretical grounds too!: Coherent grammars cannot be incomplete. . Studies in Second Language Acquisition. 2019;41(2):257-264
Metadata
Vis full innførsel
Samlinger
  • Artikler, rapporter og annet (språk og kultur) [1472]
© Cambridge University Press 2019

Bla

Bla i hele MuninEnheter og samlingerForfatterlisteTittelDatoBla i denne samlingenForfatterlisteTittelDato
Logg inn

Statistikk

Antall visninger
UiT

Munin bygger på DSpace

UiT Norges Arktiske Universitet
Universitetsbiblioteket
uit.no/ub - munin@ub.uit.no

Tilgjengelighetserklæring