A framework for results-based management in fisheries
AuthorNielsen, Kåre Nolde; Aschan, Michaela; Agnarsson, Sveinn; Ballesteros, Marta; Baudron, Alan; Borges, Maria de Fatima; Campos, Aida; Chapela, Rosa; Daníelsdóttir, Anna Kristin; Erzini, Karim; Gregersen, Olavur; Holm, Petter; Lucchetti, Alessandro; Margeirsson, Sveinn; Mendes, Hugo Vilela; Olsen, Petter; Rangel, Mafalda; Sala, Antonello; Santiago, José Luis; Sigurdardottir, Sigridur; Silva, Cristina; Sykes, Daryl; Vidarsson, Jonas Runar; Virgili, Massimo; Wise, Laura; Fernandes, Paul George
We present a framework for results-based management (RBM) of commercial fisheries. The core idea of RBM is to reduce micromanagement by delegating management responsibility to resource users. The RBM framework represents an industrial organization approach to co-management and comprises three defining processes, conducted by three independent “agents”: (i) an “authority” defines specific and measurable and achievable objectives (outcome targets, OTs) for the utilization of fisheries resources, (ii) resource user organizations (termed “operators”) take responsibility for achieving these OTs and provide documentation that (iii) allows independent “auditors” to evaluate the achievement of OTs. Using incentive mechanisms, notably deregulation, RBM grants operators the flexibility to develop and implement innovative and cost-effective ways to achieve OTs. The feasibility of implementing RBM in five European fisheries was investigated in cooperation with relevant stakeholders through artificial planning processes and computer simulations. The operators involved were enthusiastic, and new management plans were drafted based on the framework. These included socioeconomic OTs in addition to traditional stock objectives, encompassing an ecosystem approach. Several issues are in need of further research to consolidate the approach and prepare the ground for practical implementation, including: the specification of the legal and regulatory framework required to underpin RBM, details of transitional arrangements when shifting towards RBM (including cost-sharing) and the development of necessary organizational capacity for operators. Initially, we therefore envisage the framework being applied to high-value single-species fisheries, with a limited number of participants, which are adequately represented by a competent organization.
This is the peer reviewed version of the following article: Nielsen, K. N., Aschan, M., Agnarsson, S. Ballesteros, M., Baudron, A., Borges, M. d. F., ... Fernandes, P. G. (2017). A framework for results-based management in fisheries. Fish and Fisheries 19(2), 363-376., which has been published in final form at: https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12257 . This article may be used for non-commercial purposes in accordance with Wiley Terms and Conditions for Use of Self-Archived Versions.