Effect of Computational Method on Accumulated O2 Deficit

Abstract

The aim of this study was to examine how relationships between exercise intensity and the rate of energy release established in different ways, affect the calculated O₂ deficit accumulated during strenuous exercise. Aerobic energy release is readily measured by the O₂ uptake, while anaerobic energy release is by definition independent of O₂. The latter is not easily measured during strenuous exercise, but it can be estimated using the accumulated O₂ deficit principle. We have calculated it using nine different approaches. Thirteen moderately trained persons (three women) volunteered to serve as subjects for cycle ergometry. Their maximal O₂ uptake was 2.9 ± 0.6 mmol s−1 (x¯ ± s; 3.9 ± 0.8 LSTPD min−1 ). Our reference method (M0) is based on measuring the steady state O₂ uptake at the end of at least ten bouts of 10 min of exercise at constant intensity, varying between 30 and 40% of that corresponding to the maximal O₂ uptake and up to a power >90% of the maximal O₂ uptake, which is a rather time-consuming method. The outcomes of eight different simpler approaches have been compared with those of the reference method. The main result is that the accumulated O₂ deficit calculated depends a great deal on the relationship used to calculate it. A protocol of stepwise increases in exercise intensity every 4 min appeared to work well. A gross efficiency method showed the poorest performance. Another important result is that at constant power the O₂ uptake continued to increase beyond 4 min of exercise at all powers examined, also at powers well-below those corresponding to the lactate threshold. Finally, the O₂ uptake during loadless pedaling was considerably higher than resting O₂ uptake, and it appeared to follow a cubic function of the pedaling frequency. In conclusion, to obtain reliable values of the anaerobic energy release using the accumulated O₂ deficit principle, reliable relationships between exercise intensity and O₂ demand must be established.