Population structure and antimicrobial resistance among Klebsiella isolates sampled from human, animal, and environmental sources in Ghana: a cross-sectional genomic One Health study

Abstract

Background One Health approaches to address the increasing threat of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) are gaining attention. However, data on the distribution and movement of bacteria and their AMR-associated genes between clinical and non-clinical sources are scarce, especially from low-income and middle-income countries. We aimed to analyse Klebsiella isolates from various sources in Ghana and compare the prevalence of AMR with datasets from two other countries.

Methods We conducted a cross-sectional genomic One Health study. Multiple clinical, environmental, and animal sources were sampled from 78 locations (eg, hospitals, residential areas, and farms) in and around Tamale, Ghana. Clinical samples were collected through routine screening and in cases of suspected infection between March 15 and Sept 15, 2019, and samples from the wider environment were collected during a dedicated sampling effort between the dates of Aug 19, 2018, and Sept 26, 2019. Sampling locations were approximately evenly distributed from the centre of the city and steadily outwards to capture both rural and urban locations. Samples with positive growth for Klebsiella were included. Isolates of Klebsiella were obtained from the samples using Simmons citrate agar medium and characterised by antimicrobial susceptibility testing and whole-genome sequencing. A comparative analysis with Klebsiella population surveys from Pavia, Italy, and Tromsø, Norway, was performed. AMR-associated and virulence genes were detected, and the population distribution of these genes was studied.

Findings Of 957 samples collected around Tamale, Ghana, 620 were positive for Klebsiella spp. 573 Klebsiella isolates were successfully sequenced, of which 370 were Klebsiella pneumoniae. Only two hospital isolates were carbapenem-resistant. Extended-spectrum β-lactamase (ESBL) genes were relatively common among the Ghanaian clinical isolates but rare in the environmental samples. Prevalence of ESBL genes in human—hospital disease samples was 64% (14 of 22 isolates) in Ghana and 44% (four of nine isolates) in Italy, and prevalence in human—hospital carriage samples was 7% (eight of 107) in Ghana and 13% (54 of 428) in Italy; the prevalence was higher in human—hospital disease samples than in human—hospital carriage samples in both countries, and prevalence across both samples in both countries was higher than in Norway. Ghanaian isolates showed evidence of high recombination rates (recombination events compared with point mutations [r/m] 9·455) and a considerable accessory gene overlap with isolates from Italy and Norway.

Interpretation Although several AMR-associated gene classes were observed relatively frequently in non-clinical sources, ESBL, carbapenemase, and virulence genes were predominantly present only in hospital samples. These results suggest that interventions should be focused on clinical settings to have the greatest effect on the prevalence and dissemination of AMR-associated genes.

Funding European Research Council (742158), Academy of Finland EuroHPC grant, Trond Mohn Foundation (BATTALION grant), and Wellcome Trust.